Hold The Lucubrations!

I was a little embarrassed a few days ago with the outpouring, on a CBC national news broadcast, of praise for Canada’s reaction to the Fort MacMurray disaster. Reporters were suitably solemn while reporting the tragedy while the usually acerbic Rex Murphy rasped eloquently and emotionally on how wonderful Canada was as a nation to react as it had.

He recited a brief list of other tragedies from years past, from ship explosions in confined harbours, to mine disasters, ravaging floods which had destroyed homes, ruined businesses and wrecked many lives – and how Canadians had always responded with cash and caring support to set things right.

It was evidence, he said, demonstrating how great we are as a nation when tragedy strikes fellow Canadians, sometimes thousands of miles from where we live. We respond with all the aid we can offer from cash to resources to personnel; we open hearts and often homes.

But we always have – and that’s what surprised me when CBC-TV – and many editorial writers and commentators in press and on radio – sang our praises for reacting as we – and many other nations – have always reacted when fellow citizens have been struck by disaster; with action and the best help we can afford and are capable of giving.

We don’t need the self-gratification of self-praised action. We’re family and we do what families do when troubles come. We help each other

On the West Coast of Canada I live on the edge of tectonic plates which could in a matter of minutes bring earthquake devastation to some of our cities. We call it “The Big One” and many of us have prepared as best we can for a three to seven day minimum emergency without running water, fresh food supplies or medical aid. When the day comes, as we are told it most surely will, we shall be as are all communities in the immediate wake of disaster – scared, worried because help isn’t coming as quickly as we think it should (it never does, never can), but secure in the knowledge that across the far reaches of our country fellow Canadians will react as fellow Canadians have always reacted – with aid and as much comfort as they can offer.

It’s what we do. We’re family.

We can, and should be, proud Canadians,­ but never so proud that we believe we are doing something extraordinary because we simply do what bonded families should do in time of need; we reach out to help, as we should. It’s a given. Or should be.
The jingoistic lucubrations on CBC were unnecessary. A simple “thank you and well done, again” would have been ample and more fitting for the Canadian character.
(To save you a chore:Lucubration:a scholarly work – but inclined to be pompous,pedantic,stuffy. Amen.


  1. If we are family (and I agree with you that we are) then why do we let so many members of our family live on the streets, in appalling conditions with no hope of any relief

  2. Excellent question, Corinna Gililand. Perhaps less self praise and more compassion, understanding and efforts to spur the government into action to provide the necessary solutions.

  3. We Canadians seem to exercise compassion only toward those with whom we can identify. The Fort McMurray victims were working class suburbanites with kids in school etc. In other words they were like the rest of us, at least like those of us who could afford to contribute something.

    We do not identify as readily with homeless street people or the disadvantaged on our First Nations, although we have been welcoming to Syrian refugees. In fact many of us blame these unfortunate groups for their privation.

    So when the Big One hits I’ll be sending a drone to Jim carrying a bottle of scotch.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s